HOME  |  MESSAGE BOARD  |  LINKS  |  CONTACT


           Post New Message
Message  
Author  
Date  
H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Sishya   04/10/2018 02:05 AM  

Are you guys or friends hearing about H1B extension and amendment denials. Recent days , there are more rejections i am hearing, How about in your company and friends circle?

Reply

Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Guru   04/10/2018 09:23 AM  

No real incidents so far just rumors

Reply

Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   NK   04/10/2018 09:29 AM  

I personally know 3 H1B extension/amendment denials. And 2 out of 3 are from Indian companies with genuine exp and all, genuine client letter, etc unlike those fake consultanices/experiences.

So yeah, They are not rumours for sure. I shall update soon about my status, i am about to file my extension.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Sri   04/10/2018 09:33 AM  

One of Friend got Just 1 month of extension and other friend got no I94 with the amendment.

Reply

Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   M   04/10/2018 11:00 AM  

i know people with 150+k packages also getting RFE!! its brutal out there !! the rate of RFE has increased up to 70% !! tought times ahead guys !! brace yourself !!

Reply

Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   DK    04/10/2018 11:56 AM  

No master salary 65-70k

Testing jobs
Managers

Will get impacted for sure.


150k plus people are managers - Americans are better at managing then indians any day.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Cheap    04/10/2018 11:57 AM  

Fake conultants get the work done- unlike indian companies where tamil telugu rule and promote their own caste. FUcking pricks these tamilians and telugu people are.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   M   04/10/2018 12:04 PM  

that is what i am saying !! even managers are getting RFE`s !! and you sound like a racists !! Just because you have shitty Indian managers doesnt mean that all indian managers are shitty !! grow up !! you are right in a way !! but i disagree !!

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   DK    04/10/2018 12:21 PM  

I dont have shitty manager. Americans are better at managing anyday.

U dont need h1b worker for that

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Shalini   04/10/2018 01:31 PM  

it is sad to read racist comment from Cheap. No wonder he picked the 'Cheap' himself.

What a shame. Looks like Cheap is getting insulted himself and thus reflecting his reaction. Low self-esteem.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Cheap    04/10/2018 02:12 PM  

Shalini you go to walmart and talk village tamil and sleep.
good for you

Oh i forgot the sambar smell also on ur body.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Cheap ka Baap   04/10/2018 02:29 PM  

(at) cheap : You are not even confident to post your name, but have guts to scold others.

G***d mein dum hain tumhara FB profile, Linkedin profile, etc share karo..phir baat karenge.

G***d mein *** khud fill karle. Northie hain na easily fill karsakta

Reply

Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Sishya   04/10/2018 02:43 PM  

No Bro. It is not rumour. Even my amendment is denied . And 4 of my friends extension/amendment is denied in past 1 month. Not sure on what basis it is getting denied .

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Shalini   04/10/2018 02:57 PM  

fyi not that it matters but I am Marathi but foremost, proud to be an Indian and am proud of all parts of India whether it is South or what have you. The way you sound it seems you are not liked by any one. The negativity clearly depicts that.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Shalini   04/10/2018 02:58 PM  

this was meant for the dirt 'Cheap'

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Simran   04/10/2018 03:00 PM  

Hi Shalini, you are right on spot. This pathetic guy Cheap is really cheap. I am from Punjab but have Tamil and Telugu friends and they are great.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Rajiv   04/10/2018 03:28 PM  

(at) Cheap and Cheap Ke Baap, you guys should know how to behave on a public forum like this. If you really had to guts you should put in your name and not be a racist. Be proud to be an Indian and not discriminate.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   ct desi   04/10/2018 03:30 PM  

Dear cheap I know how you feel ..glad you born on some rich soil on the earth !! But topic is something else which will impact all of us please don't pay attention to those comments ..
Coming back to.the question I heard but not directly I heard who are in low salary sent back though cognizant given 10 days time to vacate the girl who is in 70k and denied extension

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Debashish   04/10/2018 03:34 PM  

I agree with you Rajiv. This topic started by Sishya was a real thing which seems to have been hijacked with this unfortunate response. Hope Cheap will reconsider these targeted response in future.
I hope this does not discourage other people who want to share their comments on the subject.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Gurmeet   04/10/2018 03:40 PM  

Thanks Debashish. We need to get back to be civil. This site is nice and is meant to help each other. Let's continue to do that.

I will like to hear more from other people about this new H1 extension or lack thereof situation.

Don't know where this is going. Is it the beginning of a new trend? Let's see how it goes. Guess things will get a bit clearer or will it.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   N   04/10/2018 04:00 PM  

Lets Discuss about the Reasons that we are getting for Denials and Solutions which might be helpfuls for others.In most of the cases i heard that People with "Analyst" Job Tile (Like Buisness Analyst, Computer analyst ) etc are getting denied. and Ofcourse again the pay ,Education background. Do any of your friends re-opened the case and got approved?Let's discuss on this lines. Thanks.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   N   04/10/2018 04:01 PM  

Lets Discuss about the Reasons that why we are getting Denials and Solutions which might be helpful for others.In most of the cases i heard that People with "Analyst" Job Tile (Like Business Analyst, Computer Analyst ) etc are getting denied. and Of course again the pay ,Education background are also the reasons. Do any of your friends re-opened the case and got approved?Let's discuss on this lines. Thanks.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Fingers crossed.   04/10/2018 04:03 PM  

That's scary. I am filing mine for extension with BA role.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Help each other   04/10/2018 04:06 PM  

Agree with Debashish and Gurmeet and others who spoke positive comments and not to divert the topic.

(at) cheap, please reconsider your comments and in the future when you say something. This is public forum and we need everyone support to keep this site live and active. Thanks in advance for considering our request.




Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Guru   04/10/2018 04:15 PM  

(at) N, good idea, people who know these details about themselves or friends, pls share the details, which might help others.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   launda !!   04/10/2018 04:57 PM  

Ahh !! screw This I think I will marry a american of desi green card !! this stress is not worth it !!

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   s   04/10/2018 05:06 PM  

I found a possible scenario on a website why h1b visa's are denied, Although i am not pointing that all of the denied extensions are due to this reason, but a few may be!

Assume this case: You are a Weblogic guru. You came to US with H-1B to work for company A to help them get their Weblogic instances in shape and you were granted 3 years long visa, because it was the norm at the time (Say Obama years). 2 years later, you have done all that was expected from you and your assigned employer told your H-1B visa holder company that they will not be needing your services anymore. Instead of doing the right thing and sending you home, your contracting agency (likes of TCS, Cognizant, Wipro etc.) decided to put you up to company B as a java support person. After all Weblogic is written in java and you have a pretty good understanding of it. Right ? Well, not so right here. US has a plethora of Java programmers and they can do the same job without requiring a special work visa and they should have preference when it comes to hiring someone for that position. And since your company farmed you out to one of these places, they did the wrong thing. Now another year later, i.e. end of your initial 3 years long period (which is not unconditional by the way, your visa may be cut short when you put transfer request for another company) you applied for extending your visa. And naturally your company (again Wipro or TCS or alike company) need to provide your new job description to the USCIS, which says Java programmer or java support. And USCIS looks at that and says, this is not something that US has a shortage of and denies extension request. Whereas, if your end employer, would have offered you a weblogic support job, the denial most probably wouldn’t happen (unless the support level you are assigned to is wildly different between companies A & B) .

Yes you are qualified as a Java programmer may be but so are many unemployed or under employed US java programmers as well. And US’ priority is to protect its own citizens and legal residents before going out and hiring foreign labor.



Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   N   04/10/2018 05:26 PM  

And again. Analyst Job title might not be true in all the cases. Only few whom i heard has this Role who got Denied.Its not generic

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Desi_best_wisher   04/10/2018 05:42 PM  

Very simple thing i want to explain -

yes h1b extension and h1b amendment denials are absolutely true - happened to my friends, family memebers.

Now why it is happening ?

Answer is - few Desi consultancies ( not all ) are NOT following rules. when an employee changes job location, they have to file amendment petition but some ignore and some don't know.
secondly, h1b extension denials are the cause of above amendment process not filing and other issues like low wages in LCA ( level 1 salary ) which h1b should NOT get paid.

Note: Above examples or instances are generic info and this should NOT be considered as any legal opinion. Please consult attorney for best legal advise.

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Sishya   04/10/2018 08:53 PM  

If we change the client also do we need to file amendment or only when location changes ?

Say if my client agrees for WFH, do i still need to file an amendment?

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Desi CT   04/11/2018 07:48 AM  

Fuck the long answers and gnan messages !! Please refer link if you feel what to be done

So future is dead dark guys save every penny no one is guaranteed and don't buy luxury items.. here dollar back in India 70 rupees and very hard to earn back in India !! Start teaching your kids some Indian languages and culture so incase if you move out suddenly they don't have hard times

Gc people and citizens of America who are past Indians don't thi no you will enjoy if lot of us left you can't stay here alone for long ..

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Desi_Well_Wisher   04/11/2018 09:46 AM  

(at) Sishya .. They have defined MSA ( Metropolitan areas ) .. If you are within the same MSA or project is 30 days or less - you do not need to file amendment and rest of the scenarios you need to file amendment if any change in location.
To answer your question - if you WFH , your primary client location won't change and you might be travelling to client location then you might NOT need any amendment. Please consult attorney for any questions - DO NOT treat this advise as Legal advise.Thanks

Reply

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: H1 Extension and Amendment Denials   Indian   04/11/2018 09:47 AM  

These are not rumours, this is true. I work with a very big multinational IT service provider - our company H1B guys have got all sorts of RFEs.

All who tried premium processing got RFEs. the intent is clear. They want the junk out of the country (as per their thoughts)

This is Karma , Indians have abused the h1b like anything. Come on - Java is a special skill ? joke, even kids know Java.

People apply thru 4-5 companies for h1b so that the probability of lottery increases. This is because you get a refund on applications not selected.
This is where the fair play is killed by indians.



Reply



www.ctdesi.com Copyright 2005-2023 All Rights reserved. This site has details and links to advertisements, events, links, messages posted by users. The users need to verify the correctness of such information and ctdesi.com do not guarantee the correctness of the content. The risk of using this content remains with the user.
Please read our Privacy Policy Send any comments to: Contact